Série de simulations préparatoires à CMIP6, LMDZ-Orchidee, CTRL : V5.80A


RUN Atlas YEAR Atlas --DJF-- Atlas --JJA-- Cloud Fraction Outputs Model Parameters Tested Parameter Period bils rt rst rlut rlutcs crest crelt cret eva pr prw
CLIMATOS 7.097 0.7823 240.4 239.6 269.4 -47.05 29.84 -17.21 3.415 2.61 27.46
V5.80A G - - - - - - - - Calipso Isccp X X 606a, LMDZsvn2720_ORCHIDEsvn3824 1980_1999 1.6754 0.605 235.299 234.694 261.736 -50.7152 27.042 -23.6732 2.91768 24.7603
V5.80B G - - - - - - - - Calipso Isccp X X 606b, LMDZsvn2720_ORCHIDEsvn3824 1980_1999 2.1755 0.991 238.509 237.518 262.005 -47.3736 24.487 -22.8866 2.95296 24.4802
V5.80Bz0 G - - - - - - - - Calipso Isccp X X V5.80B, Z0 1980_1999 0.4368 -0.738 237.932 238.67 262.833 -48.2651 24.163 -24.1021 3.13639 26.4718

Metrics computation

RMSE (Root Mean Square Error) between models and reference datasets (observations or reanalyses depending on the variable; identified at the top of the columns). The RMSE are computed on a 12-month climatological annual cycle (spatio-temporal variability + mean); they mix the information on the spatio-temporal correlation and standard-deviation ratio, as well as the mean bias. The results are shown in % of the average RMSE obtained for the set of simulations chosen as reference. A result of -10 indicates that this error is 10% lower than the average of the errors of the reference simulations.  Basically these metrics provide an overall view on whether the simulations are closer to or further of a set of reference simulations (say, the AMIP simulations, an AR4 simulation...)

Metrics with respect to coupled CMIP5 simulations (historical)

rms_xyt_ann_GLB Mean
variable pr prw psl rlut rlutcs rsut rsutcs tas uas vas
referenceName GPCP RSS ERAINT CERES CERES CERES CERES ERAINT ERAINT ERAINT
maskingRegion global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean global global global global global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean
simulationModel simulationExperiment simulationName simulationPeriod
ACCESS1-0 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +12.00 -4.45 -15.56 +7.75 -6.29 -16.25 -28.50 -1.20 -14.48 -10.01 -7.70
ACCESS1-3 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +6.79 +1.10 -10.32 +8.03 +9.55 -5.05 -11.05 -7.78 -3.69 -8.86 -2.13
BNU-ESM AMIP r1i1p1 -- -3.11 +4.33 +2.34 -3.57 +8.95 +3.19 +26.36 +25.75 +29.53 +23.44 +11.72
CCSM4 AMIP r1i1p1 -- -4.67 -26.12 -13.09 +2.93 -0.73 -7.78 -12.01 -5.47 -7.51 -4.39 -21.98 -0.73 -13.66 -10.78 -5.05 +7.09 -7.75
CESM1-CAM5 AMIP r1i1p1 -- -8.32 +4.96 -33.74 -20.70 +8.04 -9.94 -21.22 +3.59 -9.66
CMCC-CM AMIP r1i1p1 -- +6.27 +5.43 +6.29 +7.85 +1.25 +1.70 -32.93 -42.58 -24.37 -14.72 -12.18 -5.45 +15.39 -15.57 -0.46 +0.56 -17.80 -39.20 -8.95 -21.55 -31.59 -12.25 -10.68
CNRM-CM5 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +1.06 -9.93 +10.16 -4.10 -8.03 +0.55 -27.91 -25.96 -15.65 +7.94 +2.61 +21.55 +16.11 -1.20 -11.01 -29.48 -4.52 -27.22 +2.54 -10.01 -28.28 -8.44 -6.78
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 AMIP r1i1p1 -- -2.07 +6.67 -5.89 +10.52 +10.96 +21.81 +3.20 +10.09 -7.90 +3.86 -17.31 -1.47 +20.16 +14.37 +45.41 +17.54 -0.37 +10.55 -8.13 +4.98 +15.85 -4.62 +6.74
CanAM4 AMIP r1i1p1 -- -3.63 -4.80 -6.25 +8.57 -14.29 -6.42 -5.30 +14.37 +7.11 +25.75 +1.51
EC-EARTH AMIP r1i1p1 -- -11.44 -3.75 -48.08 -11.82 -17.96 -28.60 -31.93 -21.94
FGOALS-g2 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +30.23 +37.39 +30.64 -5.15 -4.26 -3.76 +21.65 +14.36 +48.60 +9.84 +15.14 -1.30 -4.04 +15.57 +18.35 +82.84 +19.13
FGOALS-s2 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +8.35 -1.22 -1.91 +5.22 +5.33 +13.37 +20.87 +39.52 +76.85 +68.44 +23.48
GFDL-CM3 AMIP r1i1p1 -- -15.61 -34.84 -9.77 +0.68 +3.52 -10.36 +4.40 -2.82 -10.34 -4.94 -11.38 -17.43 +0.56 -16.14 -16.16 -17.97 -12.32 -15.05 -13.53 -10.50
GFDL-HIRAM-C180 AMIP r1i1p1 -- -3.11 -1.71 -13.43 -16.81 +9.86 -8.29 +3.88 -7.19 -27.76 -21.55 -8.61
GFDL-HIRAM-C360 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +0.02 -1.01 -10.02 -25.32 +9.70 -13.41 +6.30 -2.40 -26.93 -21.55 -8.46
GISS-E2-R AMIP r1i1p1 -- +11.48 -0.39 +12.38 -11.41 -11.96 -9.79 -8.42 -23.05 +4.41 +5.49 +59.50 +12.63 -5.39 -1.20 -16.97 +22.76 +1.30 -5.11 +0.07 +3.83 -4.01 -5.90 +1.38
HadGEM2-A AMIP r1i1p1 -- +14.08 -4.87 -14.60 +6.30 -8.86 -16.20 -21.22 -2.99 -11.99 -7.71 -6.80
IPSL-CM5A-LR AMIP r1i1p1 -- -8.84 -0.80 -21.95 -2.97 +0.71 -6.92 +99.35 +67.90 +9.21 +25.52 +5.78 +13.65 -8.53 -12.57 -3.21 -12.50 +7.94 -0.50 +15.66 +0.37 -4.01 +5.55 +7.67
IPSL-CM5A-MR AMIP r1i1p1 -- -5.71 +24.10 -24.71 -2.06 -0.62 -9.21 +78.05 +50.81 -14.58 +23.43 +7.74 +8.76 -9.97 -16.17 -10.55 -16.42 -10.33 -15.24 -8.13 -7.71 -6.22 -3.35 +1.45
IPSL-CM5B-LR AMIP r1i1p1 -- -3.63 -2.06 +190.46 +9.48 -5.23 -0.73 -9.97 +22.16 +44.47 +2.68 +24.76
MIROC5 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +16.69 -8.69 +11.82 +5.04 -0.59 -1.46 +10.09 +20.19 +30.80 +1.23 +10.46 +22.69 -8.08 +1.80 +12.39 -5.97 +2.96 +5.95 +0.89 +8.44 -0.70 +6.82 +6.49
MPI-ESM-LR AMIP r1i1p1 -- -6.75 -13.25 -2.02 +3.77 +0.75 -4.62 -36.84 -38.58 -35.92 -7.02 +3.97 -4.37 -16.09 -20.36 -11.93 -17.72 -21.12 -13.40 -18.79 -19.24 -21.66 -16.07 -14.42
MPI-ESM-MR AMIP r1i1p1 -- -4.15 +2.15 -25.52 -2.03 +3.37 -4.66 -15.55 -19.76 -10.33 -16.94 -9.34
MRI-AGCM3-2H AMIP r1i1p1 -- -21.86 +0.89 -42.42 -31.21 -21.83 +0.97 +25.37 -12.57 -29.43 -11.17 -14.33
MRI-AGCM3-2S AMIP r1i1p1 -- -12.48 -0.66 -44.00 -29.04 -19.27 -2.78 +29.33 -7.19 -28.60 -18.09 -13.28
MRI-CGCM3 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +0.02 +43.20 +1.86 +7.85 +6.61 +25.84 -16.42 -23.10 -2.38 -4.66 -6.74 +12.97 +7.02 -27.54 -22.48 -43.84 -2.03 +0.42 -13.87 +9.60 +4.81 +8.09 -1.58
NorESM1-M AMIP r1i1p1 -- -4.67 -22.80 -13.09 +6.16 +5.71 +9.75 -10.55 -14.70 -0.34 +18.72 -14.44 +6.26 -17.71 -1.80 +4.59 +7.09 +71.87 +99.92 +56.67 +62.67 +90.87 +43.70 +17.45
bcc-csm1-1 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +8.35 +0.03 +17.36 -2.90 -3.32 -5.77 +0.71 +10.10 +15.64 +10.02 +0.35 +1.03 +2.53 -1.20 +18.35 -12.50 +3.67
bcc-csm1-1-m AMIP r1i1p1 -- +1.58 -5.01 +9.24 -0.49 -17.16 -4.54 +3.34 -16.77 -3.73
inmcm4 AMIP r1i1p1 -- +3.14 -0.09 -4.16 +16.00 +8.04 -5.11 +24.56 +78.44 +12.09 +8.44 +14.14

-50.00 -45.00 -40.00 -35.00 -30.00 -25.00 -20.00 -15.00 -10.00 -5.00 +0.00 +5.00 +10.00 +15.00 +20.00 +25.00 +30.00 +35.00 +40.00 +45.00 +50.00

Mean values over the reference simulations of the statistics (used to normalize per column)
rms_xyt_ann_GLB
variable pr prw psl rlut rlutcs rsut rsutcs tas uas vas
referenceName GPCP RSS ERAINT CERES CERES CERES CERES ERAINT ERAINT ERAINT
maskingRegion global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean global global global global global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean
0 1.919667 2.409286 1.806429 14.233333 27.792857 3.480714 302.67069 331.633846 243.667692 11.034333 6.626897 17.588966 11.118966 1.67 2.18 0.765714 1.2044 1.085455 1.219091 0.8668 0.906364 0.786364

Metrics with respect to forced-by-SST AMIP multi model

rms_xyt_ann_GLB Mean
variable pr prw psl rlut rlutcs rsut rsutcs tas uas vas
referenceName GPCP RSS ERAINT CERES CERES CERES CERES ERAINT ERAINT ERAINT
maskingRegion global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean global global global global global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean
simulationModel simulationExperiment simulationName simulationPeriod
ACCESS1-0 historical r1i1p1 -- +6.76 -3.70 -23.64 -10.80 -22.08 -24.50 -31.90 -14.34 -25.80 -18.80 -16.88
ACCESS1-3 historical r1i1p1 -- +12.33 +0.73 -19.44 -0.90 -6.42 -13.23 -9.85 -14.34 -16.35 -14.08 -8.16
BNU-ESM historical r1i1p1 -- -9.02 +4.58 +8.14 -7.15 -1.58 -4.05 +33.59 +14.92 +21.48 +10.47 +7.14
CCSM4 historical r1i1p1 -- -10.41 -21.77 -9.57 +5.30 +4.34 -3.96 -5.19 +0.43 -11.50 -10.95 -28.05 -7.90 +1.18 -12.62 -16.28 -10.00 -8.56
CESM1-BGC historical r1i1p1 -- -7.16 +5.30 -4.50 -8.13 -28.92 -6.18 -2.54 -15.21 -8.42
CESM1-CAM5 historical r1i1p1 -- -12.27 +2.08 -34.65 -18.03 +1.90 -15.92 -12.68 -8.75 -12.29
CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2 historical r1i1p1 -- -3.34 -3.34
CESM1-FASTCHEM historical r1i1p1 -- -9.02 +5.87 -0.44 -8.97 -28.54 -6.33 +0.51 -14.77 -7.71
CESM1-WACCM historical r1i1p1 -- -11.34 +9.01 +7.56 +5.72 -26.18 +4.02 -6.72 -4.44 -2.80
CMCC-CESM historical r1i1p1 -- +6.30 +11.59 +9.52 +21.62 +22.78 +21.33 +15.41 +20.52 +12.02 +6.69 +14.78
CMCC-CM historical r1i1p1 -- +3.98 +9.27 +7.61 +6.59 +5.26 -7.10 -34.04 -40.00 -29.16 -8.74 -3.94 -5.01 +8.90 +31.40 +0.31 -23.62 -38.41 -19.07 -20.69 -33.10 -15.13 -9.75
CMCC-CMS historical r1i1p1 -- -3.91 +8.73 -26.66 -5.62 -5.68 -4.20 -4.01 -15.62 -17.86 -8.31
CNRM-CM5 historical r1i1p1 -- -15.98 -14.54 -17.71 -6.63 -7.21 -0.83 -36.14 -35.32 -28.85 -10.65 -1.70 +8.69 +9.53 +2.01 -3.18 -5.12 -18.53 -36.70 -15.61 -21.63 -33.10 -23.62 -14.22
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0 historical r1i1p1 -- +25.79 -6.04 +34.29 +0.80 +8.32 -0.83 +10.54 +23.33 +11.09 +5.34 -11.27 +15.24 +34.11 +32.14 +45.59 +28.50 +4.75 +5.21 +2.37 +14.25 +19.16 +15.99 +14.49
CanCM4 historical r1i1p1 -- -9.95 -8.32 -5.09 -0.57 -5.98
CanESM2 historical r1i1p1 -- -9.48 -8.59 -11.83 -2.06 +1.13 -13.14 -10.64 -23.49 -30.21 -2.58 -19.47 -12.01 +0.14 -1.00 -2.82 -14.33 -3.98 +19.76 -6.62 +14.25 +33.80 +14.10 -4.05
EC-EARTH historical r1i1p1 -- -44.11 -4.01 -24.06
FGOALS-g2 historical r1i1p1 -- -14.59 -15.39 -18.61 -6.77 -1.24 -12.47 +10.41 +13.99 +24.15 +5.56 +33.71 -0.54 +4.68 +37.74 +43.77 +20.37 +7.80
FIO-ESM historical r1i1p1 -- -5.77 +4.08 +7.57 +2.29 -3.44 -4.05 +15.71 +0.72 +2.14
GFDL-CM2p1 historical r1i1p1 -- -1.13 -21.90 -7.15 -3.44 -1.86 -11.98 -12.19 -8.52
GFDL-CM3 historical r1i1p1 -- +0.26 -20.92 +11.23 -4.56 -2.09 +4.77 -19.45 -25.60 -17.21 +18.50 +4.14 -5.77 +0.96 -9.18 -21.74 -1.86 -8.34 -17.03 -3.85 -6.53 -18.47 -1.93 -6.58
GFDL-ESM2G historical r1i1p1 -- +5.83 +10.54 +5.81 -6.63 -1.82 +2.31 -2.26 +9.89 -0.92 -2.05 +5.01 -0.85 +4.91 +8.04 -6.09 +16.57 -9.07 -11.89 -9.39 -6.53 -9.06 -7.59 -0.24
GFDL-ESM2M historical r1i1p1 -- -3.45 -12.41 -2.33 -5.85 -2.55 -6.65 -6.67 +6.13 -7.59 -5.85 -0.83 -5.06 -1.58 +2.44 -2.09 +11.15 -14.16 -13.60 -17.00 -10.30 -11.15 -13.25 -5.57
GISS-E2-H historical r1i1p1 -- +16.51 +42.01 +11.23 -4.56 -4.00 +7.68 +5.43 -6.35 +22.23 +13.25 +37.82 +13.05 +3.86 +20.09 +0.09 +38.26 +7.66 +6.07 +9.29 +6.69 +1.39 +2.78 +11.39
GISS-E2-H-CC historical r1i1p1 -- +18.37 -3.84 -7.23 +11.27 +35.70 +9.25 -3.74 +2.01 +0.39 +4.80 +6.70
GISS-E2-R historical r1i1p1 -- +6.30 +6.29 +4.00 -4.56 -3.23 -0.38 -7.82 -24.65 +4.28 +5.87 +39.56 +11.13 -0.01 -4.01 -21.38 -8.91 -3.25 -6.76 -5.93 -4.64 -6.97 -14.19 -1.79
GISS-E2-R-CC historical r1i1p1 -- +6.76 -4.49 -7.37 +5.95 +38.93 +11.08 -0.38 -2.72 -1.80 -3.69 +4.23
HadCM3 historical r1i1p1 -- -0.66 -14.54 -5.50 +52.46 +46.28 +54.61 +22.11
HadGEM2-AO historical r1i1p1 -- +7.69 -20.93 -10.49 -18.98 -20.64 -19.76 -8.32 -20.71 -15.97 -14.23
HadGEM2-CC historical r1i1p1 -- +4.91 -2.21 +5.35 -21.86 -20.70 -30.48 -10.83
HadGEM2-ES historical r1i1p1 -- +5.83 -3.91 +6.26 -5.85 -5.26 -4.19 -13.92 -22.08 -21.40 -13.35 -4.87 +13.93 -14.88 -19.98 -23.01 -22.53 -15.02 -18.47 -20.79 -10.71
IPSL-CM5A-LR historical r1i1p1 -- -1.13 +2.04 -2.79 -8.49 -1.89 +5.22 +107.61 +76.37 +26.71 +16.83 -0.58 +14.12 -0.24 +8.47 -2.45 +18.20 +19.30 -4.20 +30.73 +0.08 -5.92 +3.73 +13.71
IPSL-CM5A-MR historical r1i1p1 -- +4.91 +22.87 +2.64 -3.20 +3.04 +0.29 +86.80 +60.70 +5.72 +16.14 +5.51 +9.76 +9.60 -9.18 -10.10 -6.74 +3.29 -16.17 +11.36 -4.64 -6.97 +0.90 +8.48
IPSL-CM5B-LR historical r1i1p1 -- +6.76 -2.42 +156.81 +13.71 +13.33 -0.75 +17.94 +53.23 +27.30 +2.92 +28.88
MIROC-ESM historical r1i1p1 -- -5.77 -0.09 -12.28 -2.56 -2.12 +15.51 +16.48 +8.18 +33.91 -1.21 +19.05 +22.34 +1.63 +1.58 +23.03 -11.08 +25.12 +32.59 +26.58 +19.91 +21.25 +17.87 +11.36
MIROC-ESM-CHEM historical r1i1p1 -- -7.63 -3.06 -14.09 -2.27 -1.78 +13.95 +16.19 +7.60 +32.75 -2.50 +20.79 +22.75 +2.30 +1.15 +19.75 -10.00 +22.94 +30.02 +24.51 +19.91 +20.21 +16.93 +10.47
MIROC4h historical r1i1p1 -- -6.70 +39.03 -8.21 +1.94 -0.36 +2.53 +3.47 -6.26 +16.34 -5.24 -16.74 -7.60 -7.83 -23.38 -17.38 -31.68 -10.53 -8.47 -10.77 -4.64 -17.42 -3.82 -5.62
MIROC5 historical r1i1p1 -- -8.56 -15.39 -16.80 +1.87 +0.90 -11.35 +16.58 +39.96 +27.33 -17.04 +6.62 +15.59 +15.63 +3.30 -16.65 +22.54 +1.84 -2.48 +3.75 -4.64 -4.88 -9.47 +2.21
MPI-ESM-LR historical r1i1p1 -- +3.98 -7.74 +12.14 +2.37 +3.39 -4.63 -37.70 -38.19 -37.17 -9.50 +1.28 -3.64 -12.01 -22.09 -27.93 -20.84 -17.07 -13.60 -14.92 -13.14 -22.65 -5.70 -12.97
MPI-ESM-MR historical r1i1p1 -- +4.91 +2.51 -34.83 -10.27 -2.95 -5.62 -14.91 -24.67 -14.89 -13.14 -11.39
MPI-ESM-P historical r1i1p1 -- +5.83 -7.31 +14.85 +2.16 +2.77 -1.50 -35.52 -35.04 -35.37 -8.36 +1.28 -3.34 -10.89 -24.24 -29.39 -21.38 -15.62 -17.03 -12.15 -11.25 -22.65 -3.82 -12.18
MRI-CGCM3 historical r1i1p1 -- +11.40 +35.63 +15.75 +5.01 +4.65 +26.04 -12.23 -11.62 -8.81 +10.82 +8.61 +13.11 +4.76 +5.46 -1.72 +18.20 +5.48 -3.34 +3.06 +15.19 +9.76 +15.04 +7.74
NorESM1-M historical r1i1p1 -- -2.52 -12.84 -2.79 -1.06 +0.52 -3.51 -18.38 -19.55 -16.01 +17.13 -14.50 +1.59 -16.70 -8.32 -5.00 -22.47 +51.31 +109.57 +33.50 +43.52 +83.97 +27.30 +10.22
NorESM1-ME historical r1i1p1 -- -5.77 -1.84 -13.39 +15.54 -9.41 +0.57 -5.23 +5.03 +52.03 +44.46 +8.20
bcc-csm1-1 historical r1i1p1 -- -4.84 -0.94 -8.66 -2.56 -0.75 -7.77 -12.55 -6.08 -5.83 -6.54 -4.93 -10.85 -3.96 +5.46 +6.65 +5.19 -2.52 +9.49 -7.31 +7.64 +21.25 +4.67 -1.17
bcc-csm1-1-m historical r1i1p1 -- +1.66 +3.37 +12.28 +15.54 -17.73 -0.75 -2.17 +3.73 -1.07 +8.58 +2.34

-50.00 -45.00 -40.00 -35.00 -30.00 -25.00 -20.00 -15.00 -10.00 -5.00 +0.00 +5.00 +10.00 +15.00 +20.00 +25.00 +30.00 +35.00 +40.00 +45.00 +50.00

Mean values over the reference simulations of the statistics (used to normalize per column)
rms_xyt_ann_GLB
variable pr prw psl rlut rlutcs rsut rsutcs tas uas vas
referenceName GPCP RSS ERAINT CERES CERES CERES CERES ERAINT ERAINT ERAINT
maskingRegion global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean global global global global global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean
0 2.154318 2.352 2.2116 13.998205 26.135217 4.466957 325.690909 353.715 276.88875 13.138837 8.047 19.707317 13.421579 2.323256 2.747391 1.844348 1.374706 1.169048 1.445714 1.059118 0.956667 1.060476

Metrics with respect to IPSLCM5A-LR (historical)

rms_xyt_ann_GLB Mean
variable pr prw psl rlut rlutcs rsut rsutcs tas uas vas
referenceName GPCP RSS ERAINT CERES CERES CERES CERES ERAINT ERAINT ERAINT
maskingRegion global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean global global global global global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean
simulationModel simulationExperiment simulationName simulationPeriod
LMDZ6 clim AR4.0ada 1982_1991 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00 +0.00

-50.00 -45.00 -40.00 -35.00 -30.00 -25.00 -20.00 -15.00 -10.00 -5.00 +0.00 +5.00 +10.00 +15.00 +20.00 +25.00 +30.00 +35.00 +40.00 +45.00 +50.00

Mean values over the reference simulations of the statistics (used to normalize per column)
rms_xyt_ann_GLB
variable pr prw psl rlut rlutcs rsut rsutcs tas uas vas
referenceName GPCP RSS ERAINT CERES CERES CERES CERES ERAINT ERAINT ERAINT
maskingRegion global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean global global global global global land ocean global land ocean global land ocean
0 1.91 1.97 1.56 14.06 22.71 3.3 575.33 998.57 245.02 13.94 6.83 19.24 10.27 1.4 2.28 0.63 1.27 1.09 1.26 2.736309 1.857032 3.079725