Série de simulations préparatoires à CMIP6, LMDZ-Orchidee, CTRL : NPv5.3

RUN	Atlas YEAR	Atlas --DJF--	Atlas --JJA--	Cloud Fraction	Outputs	Model Parameters	Tested Parameter	Period	bils	rt	rst	rlut	rlutcs	crest	crelt	cret	eva	pr	prw
CLIMATOS									7.097	0.7823	240.4	239.6	269.4	-47.05	29.84	-17.21	3.415	2.61	27.46
NPv5.3	G N S	G N S	G N S	Calipso Isccp	X	X	Runs de l'ete, IPSL-CM6.0.1	1982_1989	0.0468	-0.867	241.813	242.68	265.952	-48.1478	23.272	-24.8758		3.05269	25.2791
NPv5.40	G N S	G N S	G N S	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.2	1982_1989	1.9904	1.1915	249.989	248.798	265.916	-42.1175	17.118	-24.9995		3.07754	25.1919
NPv5.5	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.3	1982_1989	0.943	-0.674	239.31	239.984	265.975	-47.9326	25.991	-21.9416		3.07924	26.103
NPv5.63	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.4	1982_1989	2.64	1.075	240.054	238.979	266.013	-47.1826	27.034	-20.1486		3.06236	26.0366
NPv5.70	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.5	1982_1989	2.9858	1.78	240.902	239.122	265.126	-45.143	26.004	-19.139		2.97849	24.8241
V5.70a	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.5	1980_1989	2.8107	1.635	240.654	239.019	265.205	-45.5916	26.186	-19.4056		3.01581	24.6266
V5.70aZ0	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.5 noveaux z0	1980_1989	1.2539	0.079	240.178	240.099	265.841	-46.1032	25.742	-20.3612		3.15974	26.8722
V5.81rim1	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.7 Premier réglage (equivalent 606)	1980_1999	4.1649	3.05	239.853	236.803	262.453	-46.3429	25.65	-20.6929		3.11231	26.7982
V5.81rim2	G - -	G - -	G - -	Calipso Isccp	X	X	6.0.7 Second réglage	1980_1999	4.7174	3.335	240.333	236.998	262.482	-45.9013	25.484	-20.4173		3.10281	27.0787
RIM1607b	G - -	G - -	G - -	X	X	X	Premier reglage, simus Ionela	1987_1996	5.0007	3.914	240.549	236.635	262.442	-46.7696	25.807	-20.9626		3.15339	26.7825
CLC30.RIM1607b	G - -	G - -	G - -	X	X	X	le meme avec cld_lc=0.3g/kg, reglage definitif 606 ?	1987_1996	3.1015	2.053	237.633	235.58	262.396	-49.6789	26.816	-22.8629		3.13773	26.814

Metrics computation

RMSE (Root Mean Square Error) between models and reference datasets (observations or reanalyses depending on the variable; identified at the top of the columns). The RMSE are computed on a 12-month climatological annual cycle (spatio-temporal variability + mean); they mix the information on the spatio-temporal correlation and standard-deviation ratio, as well as the mean bias. The results are shown in % of the average RMSE obtained for the set of simulations chosen as reference. A result of -10 indicates that this error is 10% lower than the average of the errors of the reference simulations. Basically these metrics provide an overall view on whether the simulations are closer to or further of a set of reference simulations (say, the AMIP simulations, an AR4 simulation...)

Metrics with respect to coupled CMIP5 simulations (historical)

				rms_xyt_ann_GLB																						Mean
			variable	pr			prw			psl			rlut	rlutcs	rsut	rsutcs	tas			uas			vas
			referenceName	GPCP			RSS			ERAINT			CERES	CERES	CERES	CERES	ERAINT			ERAINT			ERAINT
			maskingRegion	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	global	global	global	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean
simulationModel	simulationExperiment	simulationName	simulationPeriod
LMDZOR	clim	NPv5.3	1982_1989	+5.23	-26.12	+8.50	+0.12	-18.43	+9.75	+80.70	+163.21	+25.57	+22.25	-0.71	+17.29	+7.29	+70.06	+114.22	+60.63	+12.09	-5.11	+18.12	+394.92	+151.55	+546.01	+75.33
		NPv5.40	1982_1989	+12.00	-1.63	-4.78	+0.96	-17.14	+1.99	+90.46	+167.33	+42.74	+39.84	-7.80	+24.57	+14.49	+77.25	+111.93	+97.20	+11.26	-7.87	+19.76	+393.77	+150.45	+542.20	+79.95
		NPv5.70a	1980_1989	+13.76	-9.93	-13.82	+0.49	-17.21	-7.51	+18.30	+50.78	+2.84	+1.86	-14.24	-4.06	+2.71	+10.15	+34.54	+20.59	+0.57	-16.62	+6.33	-1.62	-10.15	+0.73	+3.11
		NPv5.70aZ0	1980_1989	+23.98	-3.71	+4.07	+10.73	-10.44	+39.91	+21.46	+47.34	+13.09	+9.93	-14.44	-1.19	-1.43	-7.78	+16.51	-17.72	+1.30	-9.72	+3.36	+423.77	+202.31	+573.99	+60.24
ACCESS1-0	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+12.00			-4.45			-15.56			+7.75	-6.29	-16.25	-28.50	-1.20			-14.48			-10.01			-7.70
ACCESS1-3	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+6.79			+1.10			-10.32			+8.03	+9.55	-5.05	-11.05	-7.78			-3.69			-8.86			-2.13
BNU-ESM	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-3.11			+4.33			+2.34			-3.57	+8.95	+3.19	+26.36	+25.75			+29.53			+23.44			+11.72
CCSM4	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-4.67	-26.12	-13.09	+2.93	-0.73	-7.78	-12.01	-5.47	-7.51	-4.39	-21.98	-0.73	-13.66	-10.78	-5.05	+7.09							-7.75
CESM1-CAM5	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-8.32			+4.96			-33.74			-20.70	+8.04	-9.94	-21.22	+3.59									-9.66
CMCC-CM	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+6.27	+5.43	+6.29	+7.85	+1.25	+1.70	-32.93	-42.58	-24.37	-14.72	-12.18	-5.45	+15.39	-15.57	-0.46	+0.56	-17.80	-39.20	-8.95	-21.55	-31.59	-12.25	-10.68
CNRM-CM5	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+1.06	-9.93	+10.16	-4.10	-8.03	+0.55	-27.91	-25.96	-15.65	+7.94	+2.61	+21.55	+16.11	-1.20	-11.01	-29.48	-4.52	-27.22	+2.54	-10.01	-28.28	-8.44	-6.78
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-2.07	+6.67	-5.89	+10.52	+10.96	+21.81	+3.20	+10.09	-7.90	+3.86	-17.31	-1.47	+20.16	+14.37	+45.41	+17.54	-0.37	+10.55	-8.13	+4.98	+15.85	-4.62	+6.74
CanAM4	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-3.63			-4.80			-6.25			+8.57	-14.29	-6.42	-5.30	+14.37			+7.11			+25.75			+1.51
EC-EARTH	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-11.44			-3.75			-48.08			-11.82				-17.96			-28.60			-31.93			-21.94
FGOALS-g2	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+30.23	+37.39	+30.64	-5.15	-4.26	-3.76	+21.65	+14.36	+48.60	+9.84	+15.14	-1.30	-4.04	+15.57	+18.35	+82.84							+19.13
FGOALS-s2	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+8.35			-1.22			-1.91			+5.22	+5.33	+13.37	+20.87	+39.52			+76.85			+68.44			+23.48
GFDL-CM3	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-15.61	-34.84	-9.77	+0.68	+3.52	-10.36				+4.40	-2.82	-10.34	-4.94	-11.38	-17.43	+0.56	-16.14	-16.16	-17.97	-12.32	-15.05	-13.53	-10.50
GFDL-HIRAM-C180	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-3.11			-1.71			-13.43			-16.81	+9.86	-8.29	+3.88	-7.19			-27.76			-21.55			-8.61
GFDL-HIRAM-C360	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+0.02			-1.01			-10.02			-25.32	+9.70	-13.41	+6.30	-2.40			-26.93			-21.55			-8.46
GISS-E2-R	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+11.48	-0.39	+12.38	-11.41	-11.96	-9.79	-8.42	-23.05	+4.41	+5.49	+59.50	+12.63	-5.39	-1.20	-16.97	+22.76	+1.30	-5.11	+0.07	+3.83	-4.01	-5.90	+1.38
HadGEM2-A	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+14.08			-4.87			-14.60			+6.30	-8.86	-16.20	-21.22	-2.99			-11.99			-7.71			-6.80
IPSL-CM5A-LR	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-8.84	-0.80	-21.95	-2.97	+0.71	-6.92	+99.35	+67.90	+9.21	+25.52	+5.78	+13.65	-8.53	-12.57	-3.21	-12.50	+7.94	-0.50	+15.66	+0.37	-4.01	+5.55	+7.67
IPSL-CM5A-MR	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-5.71	+24.10	-24.71	-2.06	-0.62	-9.21	+78.05	+50.81	-14.58	+23.43	+7.74	+8.76	-9.97	-16.17	-10.55	-16.42	-10.33	-15.24	-8.13	-7.71	-6.22	-3.35	+1.45
IPSL-CM5B-LR	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-3.63			-2.06			+190.46			+9.48	-5.23	-0.73	-9.97	+22.16			+44.47			+2.68			+24.76
MIROC5	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+16.69	-8.69	+11.82	+5.04	-0.59	-1.46	+10.09	+20.19	+30.80	+1.23	+10.46	+22.69	-8.08	+1.80	+12.39	-5.97	+2.96	+5.95	+0.89	+8.44	-0.70	+6.82	+6.49
MPI-ESM-LR	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-6.75	-13.25	-2.02	+3.77	+0.75	-4.62	-36.84	-38.58	-35.92	-7.02	+3.97	-4.37	-16.09	-20.36	-11.93	-17.72	-21.12	-13.40	-18.79	-19.24	-21.66	-16.07	-14.42
MPI-ESM-MR	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-4.15			+2.15			-25.52			-2.03	+3.37	-4.66	-15.55	-19.76			-10.33			-16.94			-9.34
MRI-AGCM3-2H	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-21.86			+0.89			-42.42			-31.21	-21.83	+0.97	+25.37	-12.57			-29.43			-11.17			-14.33
MRI-AGCM3-2S	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-12.48			-0.66			-44.00			-29.04	-19.27	-2.78	+29.33	-7.19			-28.60			-18.09			-13.28
MRI-CGCM3	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+0.02	+43.20	+1.86	+7.85	+6.61	+25.84	-16.42	-23.10	-2.38	-4.66	-6.74	+12.97	+7.02	-27.54	-22.48	-43.84	-2.03	+0.42	-13.87	+9.60	+4.81	+8.09	-1.58
NorESM1-M	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	-4.67	-22.80	-13.09	+6.16	+5.71	+9.75	-10.55	-14.70	-0.34	+18.72	-14.44	+6.26	-17.71	-1.80	+4.59	+7.09	+71.87	+99.92	+56.67	+62.67	+90.87	+43.70	+17.45
bcc-csm1-1	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+8.35	+0.03	+17.36	-2.90	-3.32	-5.77	+0.71	+10.10	+15.64	+10.02	+0.35	+1.03	+2.53	-1.20	+18.35	-12.50							+3.67
bcc-csm1-1-m	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+1.58			-5.01			+9.24			-0.49	-17.16	-4.54	+3.34	-16.77									-3.73
inmcm4	AMIP	r1i1p1	--	+3.14			-0.09			-4.16			+16.00	+8.04	-5.11	+24.56	+78.44			+12.09			+8.44			+14.14

-50.00

-45.00

-40.00

-35.00

-30.00

-25.00

-20.00

-15.00

-10.00

-5.00

+0.00

+5.00

+10.00

+15.00

+20.00

+25.00

+30.00

+35.00

+40.00

+45.00

+50.00

Mean values over the reference simulations of the statistics (used to normalize per column)

	rms_xyt_ann_GLB
variable	pr			prw			psl			rlut	rlutcs	rsut	rsutcs	tas			uas			vas
referenceName	GPCP			RSS			ERAINT			CERES	CERES	CERES	CERES	ERAINT			ERAINT			ERAINT
maskingRegion	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	global	global	global	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean
0	1.919667	2.409286	1.806429	14.233333	27.792857	3.480714	302.67069	331.633846	243.667692	11.034333	6.626897	17.588966	11.118966	1.67	2.18	0.765714	1.2044	1.085455	1.219091	0.8668	0.906364	0.786364

Metrics with respect to forced-by-SST AMIP multi model

				rms_xyt_ann_GLB																						Mean
			variable	pr			prw			psl			rlut	rlutcs	rsut	rsutcs	tas			uas			vas
			referenceName	GPCP			RSS			ERAINT			CERES	CERES	CERES	CERES	ERAINT			ERAINT			ERAINT
			maskingRegion	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	global	global	global	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean
simulationModel	simulationExperiment	simulationName	simulationPeriod
LMDZOR	clim	NPv5.3	1982_1989	-6.23	-24.32	-11.38	+1.80	-13.26	-14.48	+67.93	+146.78	+10.50	+2.67	-18.23	+4.68	-11.11	+22.24	+69.98	-33.31	-1.80	-11.89	-0.40	+305.05	+138.33	+379.03	+45.57
		NPv5.40	1982_1989	-0.20	+0.77	-22.23	+2.66	-11.88	-20.53	+77.00	+150.64	+25.61	+17.44	-24.07	+11.18	-5.15	+27.41	+68.16	-18.13	-2.52	-14.46	+0.99	+304.11	+137.28	+376.20	+49.10
		NPv5.70a	1980_1989	+1.37	-7.74	-29.61	+2.18	-11.95	-27.93	+9.94	+41.37	-9.50	-14.45	-29.38	-14.37	-14.91	-20.82	+6.76	-49.93	-11.89	-22.58	-10.33	-19.48	-14.88	-25.31	-12.43
		NPv5.70aZ0	1980_1989	+10.48	-1.36	-14.99	+12.59	-4.76	+9.02	+12.87	+38.14	-0.48	-7.68	-29.54	-11.81	-18.34	-33.71	-7.55	-65.84	-11.25	-16.17	-12.85	+328.66	+186.41	+399.78	+34.62
ACCESS1-0	historical	r1i1p1	--	+6.76			-3.70			-23.64			-10.80	-22.08	-24.50	-31.90	-14.34			-25.80			-18.80			-16.88
ACCESS1-3	historical	r1i1p1	--	+12.33			+0.73			-19.44			-0.90	-6.42	-13.23	-9.85	-14.34			-16.35			-14.08			-8.16
BNU-ESM	historical	r1i1p1	--	-9.02			+4.58			+8.14			-7.15	-1.58	-4.05	+33.59	+14.92			+21.48			+10.47			+7.14
CCSM4	historical	r1i1p1	--	-10.41	-21.77	-9.57	+5.30	+4.34	-3.96	-5.19	+0.43	-11.50	-10.95	-28.05	-7.90	+1.18	-12.62	-16.28	-10.00							-8.56
CESM1-BGC	historical	r1i1p1	--	-7.16			+5.30			-4.50			-8.13	-28.92	-6.18	-2.54	-15.21									-8.42
CESM1-CAM5	historical	r1i1p1	--	-12.27			+2.08			-34.65			-18.03	+1.90	-15.92	-12.68	-8.75									-12.29
CESM1-CAM5-1-FV2	historical	r1i1p1	--										-3.34													-3.34
CESM1-FASTCHEM	historical	r1i1p1	--	-9.02			+5.87			-0.44			-8.97	-28.54	-6.33	+0.51	-14.77									-7.71
CESM1-WACCM	historical	r1i1p1	--	-11.34			+9.01			+7.56			+5.72	-26.18	+4.02	-6.72	-4.44									-2.80
CMCC-CESM	historical	r1i1p1	--	+6.30			+11.59			+9.52			+21.62	+22.78	+21.33	+15.41	+20.52			+12.02			+6.69			+14.78
CMCC-CM	historical	r1i1p1	--	+3.98	+9.27	+7.61	+6.59	+5.26	-7.10	-34.04	-40.00	-29.16	-8.74	-3.94	-5.01		+8.90	+31.40	+0.31	-23.62	-38.41	-19.07	-20.69	-33.10	-15.13	-9.75
CMCC-CMS	historical	r1i1p1	--	-3.91			+8.73			-26.66			-5.62	-5.68	-4.20		-4.01			-15.62			-17.86			-8.31
CNRM-CM5	historical	r1i1p1	--	-15.98	-14.54	-17.71	-6.63	-7.21	-0.83	-36.14	-35.32	-28.85	-10.65	-1.70	+8.69	+9.53	+2.01	-3.18	-5.12	-18.53	-36.70	-15.61	-21.63	-33.10	-23.62	-14.22
CSIRO-Mk3-6-0	historical	r1i1p1	--	+25.79	-6.04	+34.29	+0.80	+8.32	-0.83	+10.54	+23.33	+11.09	+5.34	-11.27	+15.24	+34.11	+32.14	+45.59	+28.50	+4.75	+5.21	+2.37	+14.25	+19.16	+15.99	+14.49
CanCM4	historical	r1i1p1	--	-9.95						-8.32			-5.09				-0.57									-5.98
CanESM2	historical	r1i1p1	--	-9.48	-8.59	-11.83	-2.06	+1.13	-13.14	-10.64	-23.49	-30.21	-2.58	-19.47	-12.01	+0.14	-1.00	-2.82	-14.33	-3.98	+19.76	-6.62	+14.25	+33.80	+14.10	-4.05
EC-EARTH	historical	r1i1p1	--							-44.11							-4.01									-24.06
FGOALS-g2	historical	r1i1p1	--	-14.59	-15.39	-18.61	-6.77	-1.24	-12.47	+10.41	+13.99	+24.15	+5.56	+33.71	-0.54	+4.68	+37.74	+43.77	+20.37							+7.80
FIO-ESM	historical	r1i1p1	--	-5.77			+4.08			+7.57			+2.29	-3.44	-4.05	+15.71	+0.72									+2.14
GFDL-CM2p1	historical	r1i1p1	--	-1.13						-21.90			-7.15		-3.44		-1.86			-11.98			-12.19			-8.52
GFDL-CM3	historical	r1i1p1	--	+0.26	-20.92	+11.23	-4.56	-2.09	+4.77	-19.45	-25.60	-17.21	+18.50	+4.14	-5.77	+0.96	-9.18	-21.74	-1.86	-8.34	-17.03	-3.85	-6.53	-18.47	-1.93	-6.58
GFDL-ESM2G	historical	r1i1p1	--	+5.83	+10.54	+5.81	-6.63	-1.82	+2.31	-2.26	+9.89	-0.92	-2.05	+5.01	-0.85	+4.91	+8.04	-6.09	+16.57	-9.07	-11.89	-9.39	-6.53	-9.06	-7.59	-0.24
GFDL-ESM2M	historical	r1i1p1	--	-3.45	-12.41	-2.33	-5.85	-2.55	-6.65	-6.67	+6.13	-7.59	-5.85	-0.83	-5.06	-1.58	+2.44	-2.09	+11.15	-14.16	-13.60	-17.00	-10.30	-11.15	-13.25	-5.57
GISS-E2-H	historical	r1i1p1	--	+16.51	+42.01	+11.23	-4.56	-4.00	+7.68	+5.43	-6.35	+22.23	+13.25	+37.82	+13.05	+3.86	+20.09	+0.09	+38.26	+7.66	+6.07	+9.29	+6.69	+1.39	+2.78	+11.39
GISS-E2-H-CC	historical	r1i1p1	--	+18.37			-3.84			-7.23			+11.27	+35.70	+9.25	-3.74	+2.01			+0.39			+4.80			+6.70
GISS-E2-R	historical	r1i1p1	--	+6.30	+6.29	+4.00	-4.56	-3.23	-0.38	-7.82	-24.65	+4.28	+5.87	+39.56	+11.13	-0.01	-4.01	-21.38	-8.91	-3.25	-6.76	-5.93	-4.64	-6.97	-14.19	-1.79
GISS-E2-R-CC	historical	r1i1p1	--	+6.76			-4.49			-7.37			+5.95	+38.93	+11.08	-0.38	-2.72			-1.80			-3.69			+4.23
HadCM3	historical	r1i1p1	--	-0.66	-14.54	-5.50				+52.46	+46.28	+54.61														+22.11
HadGEM2-AO	historical	r1i1p1	--	+7.69						-20.93			-10.49	-18.98	-20.64	-19.76	-8.32			-20.71			-15.97			-14.23
HadGEM2-CC	historical	r1i1p1	--	+4.91	-2.21	+5.35				-21.86	-20.70	-30.48														-10.83
HadGEM2-ES	historical	r1i1p1	--	+5.83	-3.91	+6.26	-5.85	-5.26	-4.19				-13.92	-22.08	-21.40	-13.35	-4.87	+13.93	-14.88	-19.98	-23.01	-22.53	-15.02	-18.47	-20.79	-10.71
IPSL-CM5A-LR	historical	r1i1p1	--	-1.13	+2.04	-2.79	-8.49	-1.89	+5.22	+107.61	+76.37	+26.71	+16.83	-0.58	+14.12	-0.24	+8.47	-2.45	+18.20	+19.30	-4.20	+30.73	+0.08	-5.92	+3.73	+13.71
IPSL-CM5A-MR	historical	r1i1p1	--	+4.91	+22.87	+2.64	-3.20	+3.04	+0.29	+86.80	+60.70	+5.72	+16.14	+5.51	+9.76	+9.60	-9.18	-10.10	-6.74	+3.29	-16.17	+11.36	-4.64	-6.97	+0.90	+8.48
IPSL-CM5B-LR	historical	r1i1p1	--	+6.76			-2.42			+156.81			+13.71	+13.33	-0.75	+17.94	+53.23			+27.30			+2.92			+28.88
MIROC-ESM	historical	r1i1p1	--	-5.77	-0.09	-12.28	-2.56	-2.12	+15.51	+16.48	+8.18	+33.91	-1.21	+19.05	+22.34	+1.63	+1.58	+23.03	-11.08	+25.12	+32.59	+26.58	+19.91	+21.25	+17.87	+11.36
MIROC-ESM-CHEM	historical	r1i1p1	--	-7.63	-3.06	-14.09	-2.27	-1.78	+13.95	+16.19	+7.60	+32.75	-2.50	+20.79	+22.75	+2.30	+1.15	+19.75	-10.00	+22.94	+30.02	+24.51	+19.91	+20.21	+16.93	+10.47
MIROC4h	historical	r1i1p1	--	-6.70	+39.03	-8.21	+1.94	-0.36	+2.53	+3.47	-6.26	+16.34	-5.24	-16.74	-7.60	-7.83	-23.38	-17.38	-31.68	-10.53	-8.47	-10.77	-4.64	-17.42	-3.82	-5.62
MIROC5	historical	r1i1p1	--	-8.56	-15.39	-16.80	+1.87	+0.90	-11.35	+16.58	+39.96	+27.33	-17.04	+6.62	+15.59	+15.63	+3.30	-16.65	+22.54	+1.84	-2.48	+3.75	-4.64	-4.88	-9.47	+2.21
MPI-ESM-LR	historical	r1i1p1	--	+3.98	-7.74	+12.14	+2.37	+3.39	-4.63	-37.70	-38.19	-37.17	-9.50	+1.28	-3.64	-12.01	-22.09	-27.93	-20.84	-17.07	-13.60	-14.92	-13.14	-22.65	-5.70	-12.97
MPI-ESM-MR	historical	r1i1p1	--	+4.91			+2.51			-34.83			-10.27	-2.95	-5.62	-14.91	-24.67			-14.89			-13.14			-11.39
MPI-ESM-P	historical	r1i1p1	--	+5.83	-7.31	+14.85	+2.16	+2.77	-1.50	-35.52	-35.04	-35.37	-8.36	+1.28	-3.34	-10.89	-24.24	-29.39	-21.38	-15.62	-17.03	-12.15	-11.25	-22.65	-3.82	-12.18
MRI-CGCM3	historical	r1i1p1	--	+11.40	+35.63	+15.75	+5.01	+4.65	+26.04	-12.23	-11.62	-8.81	+10.82	+8.61	+13.11	+4.76	+5.46	-1.72	+18.20	+5.48	-3.34	+3.06	+15.19	+9.76	+15.04	+7.74
NorESM1-M	historical	r1i1p1	--	-2.52	-12.84	-2.79	-1.06	+0.52	-3.51	-18.38	-19.55	-16.01	+17.13	-14.50	+1.59	-16.70	-8.32	-5.00	-22.47	+51.31	+109.57	+33.50	+43.52	+83.97	+27.30	+10.22
NorESM1-ME	historical	r1i1p1	--	-5.77			-1.84			-13.39			+15.54	-9.41	+0.57	-5.23	+5.03			+52.03			+44.46			+8.20
bcc-csm1-1	historical	r1i1p1	--	-4.84	-0.94	-8.66	-2.56	-0.75	-7.77	-12.55	-6.08	-5.83	-6.54	-4.93	-10.85	-3.96	+5.46	+6.65	+5.19	-2.52	+9.49	-7.31	+7.64	+21.25	+4.67	-1.17
bcc-csm1-1-m	historical	r1i1p1	--	+1.66			+3.37			+12.28			+15.54	-17.73	-0.75	-2.17	+3.73			-1.07			+8.58			+2.34

-50.00

-45.00

-40.00

-35.00

-30.00

-25.00

-20.00

-15.00

-10.00

-5.00

+0.00

+5.00

+10.00

+15.00

+20.00

+25.00

+30.00

+35.00

+40.00

+45.00

+50.00

Mean values over the reference simulations of the statistics (used to normalize per column)

	rms_xyt_ann_GLB
variable	pr			prw			psl			rlut	rlutcs	rsut	rsutcs	tas			uas			vas
referenceName	GPCP			RSS			ERAINT			CERES	CERES	CERES	CERES	ERAINT			ERAINT			ERAINT
maskingRegion	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	global	global	global	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean
0	2.154318	2.352	2.2116	13.998205	26.135217	4.466957	325.690909	353.715	276.88875	13.138837	8.047	19.707317	13.421579	2.323256	2.747391	1.844348	1.374706	1.169048	1.445714	1.059118	0.956667	1.060476

Metrics with respect to IPSLCM5A-LR (historical)

				rms_xyt_ann_GLB																						Mean
			variable	pr			prw			psl			rlut	rlutcs	rsut	rsutcs	tas			uas			vas
			referenceName	GPCP			RSS			ERAINT			CERES	CERES	CERES	CERES	ERAINT			ERAINT			ERAINT
			maskingRegion	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	global	global	global	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean
simulationModel	simulationExperiment	simulationName	simulationPeriod
LMDZOR	clim	NPv5.3	1982_1989	+5.76	-9.64	+25.64	+1.35	-0.18	+15.76	-4.93	-12.58	+24.88	-3.23	-3.66	+7.22	+16.16	+102.86	+104.82	+95.24	+6.30	-5.50	+14.29	+56.78	+22.78	+64.95	+23.87
		NPv5.40	1982_1989	+12.57	+20.30	+10.26	+2.20	+1.41	+7.58	+0.20	-11.22	+41.95	+10.69	-10.54	+13.88	+23.95	+111.43	+102.63	+139.68	+5.51	-8.26	+15.87	+56.42	+22.24	+63.98	+28.76
		NPv5.70a	1980_1989	+14.34	+10.15	-0.20	+1.73	+1.33	-2.45	-37.76	-49.93	+2.28	-19.37	-16.79	-12.29	+11.20	+31.40	+28.64	+46.57	-4.63	-16.96	+2.88	-68.84	-56.15	-74.28	-9.51
		NPv5.70aZ0	1980_1989	+24.61	+17.77	+20.51	+12.09	+9.60	+47.58	-36.10	-51.07	+12.47	-12.98	-16.98	-9.67	+6.72	+10.00	+11.40	+0.00	-3.94	-10.09	+0.00	+65.92	+47.55	+72.09	+9.88
LMDZ6	clim	AR4.0ada	1982_1991	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00	+0.00

-50.00

-45.00

-40.00

-35.00

-30.00

-25.00

-20.00

-15.00

-10.00

-5.00

+0.00

+5.00

+10.00

+15.00

+20.00

+25.00

+30.00

+35.00

+40.00

+45.00

+50.00

Mean values over the reference simulations of the statistics (used to normalize per column)

	rms_xyt_ann_GLB
variable	pr			prw			psl			rlut	rlutcs	rsut	rsutcs	tas			uas			vas
referenceName	GPCP			RSS			ERAINT			CERES	CERES	CERES	CERES	ERAINT			ERAINT			ERAINT
maskingRegion	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	global	global	global	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean	global	land	ocean
0	1.91	1.97	1.56	14.06	22.71	3.3	575.33	998.57	245.02	13.94	6.83	19.24	10.27	1.4	2.28	0.63	1.27	1.09	1.26	2.736309	1.857032	3.079725